Kill the Traditional Breadwinner

Back in “the good old days,” men were the breadwinners, and we ladies were nice-to-have arm candy, reproductive systems, and homemakers. We had no access to finances, couldn’t apply for credit cards, couldn’t own property. If we weren’t married off to a well-endowed gentleman (ahem, financially) we were SOL. As for our male counterparts, generally, if you weren’t a viable “provider,” good luck winning the girl, schmuck.

Thankfully, a lot has changed in the past few decades. Women are now making up almost half of the workforce, and while we’re still earning Ladybucks, that wage gap is slowly but surely going to close. We’re independent and capable, and the pressure should be off men to support their partners.

Despite this change, there still seems to be a conflation between masculinity and bringing the bacon home – and not just because it’s bacon.

This frustrating fun-fact has become a frequent issue for me, especially now that I’ve experienced first-hand the fun of millennial dating. I’m not going out and flaunting my shred of business and finance savvy anywhere (you know, aside from this blog) but eventually things will come up in some way or another.

For instance, back when I was renting an apartment, one gentleman offered to pick me up for date 3+. When he arrived, he commented on the apartment complex I was in, thanks to the gaudy fountain and fancy-pants driveway setup (totally wasn’t killing that stealth wealth game there).

You must have a lot of roommates.

Are your parents helping you out?

So what is it that you do again?

It’s awkward. It’s awkward in part because I feel like it’s embarrassing – like I’m trying to out-man the fella by showing off a flashy life, even though in reality I just wanted to live biking distance from my office and had to scramble to find a new place during the holidays. It’s also awkward because, at least with some of the fellows I’ve met, it makes them uncomfortable to know that I’m able to support a life that may include such unnecessary swank.

And the reality is, while #NotAllMen will huff and puff or be threatened by a woman who out-earns them, there are still those who take it as a personal blow. Even worse, other men will give these gentlemen hell about it and make them feel bad about themselves:

  • Mr. Date #3 quickly shut down any conversation about work for the next few weeks; we found ourselves with an unspoken “don’t ask, don’t tell” rule.
  • An ex’s father teased him in front of me when we split the cost of lunch and announced that this “wasn’t how I raised you.” In front of the entire restaurant. It seemed benign to me, but it really affected the guy, and became a point of contention discussion weeks later.
  • One memorable suitor belittled my job, saying I only do well because of my looks. Thanks?

Luckily, since moving into my own house, that awkwardness is at least delayed. There’s no ostentatious fountain out front, and everyone can assume I’m renting like any other Los Angeles millennial.

But the reality is I’m proud of all the things I have going for me, and that includes the house milestone, my job, my opinions…

You can bet I’m open as hell about my political leanings on date number one, my (lack of) religious leanings, my egregious ideas about women being people, and whatever else comes up. There’s no surprise that the unsolicited feedback I’ve gotten on first dates is “you’re (very/too) honest.”

But is there any point in hiding things from potential suitors on the off chance they’d be uncomfortable? What’s the point of dating if you can’t be honest right out the gate?

There will come a day when I meet someone I like enough to share my, I don’t know, blog. Or frustrations with my mortgage, assuming those come. Or goal of early retirement. At some point in my life, this is going to come up again, and it’ll likely be just as much of an awkward conversation as last time.

The only way this will become less awkward or taboo is if we, as a society, can stop thinking of men as the “providers.”

Money isn’t a direct product of testosterone, and shouldn’t be treated as a gendered tool.

Another insidious way I’ve seen this form of sexism deter happiness is this idea is this: if a man can’t “take care of his woman” (god, I hate that phrase), then he doesn’t deserve to date one. An otherwise very progressive feminist friend of mine internalized the idea that, because of his nontraditional profession, he wasn’t worthy of a romantic connection. He was taught at a young age that, in order to have a romantic relationship, he would have to prove his value by being able to financially support another human being. No stable income, no companionship.

Oy vey.

It’s time to confront this. I don’t expect it to suddenly become polite to talk about money early on, but let’s at least get comfortable with the idea that women can do well – sometimes even better than their romantic male counterparts – without it threatening anyone’s sense of masculinity. We women are thriving, just like men.

I grew up with two parents that treated each other as equals, and are equals, but if I had to guess, I’d say my mom is more career-oriented and perhaps even out-earns my dad. I grew up with a role model who is an incredibly smart, powerful, and successful woman.

And guess what, my dad is absolutely every bit of a role model to me even though he might not be the chief breadwinner of the household. Neither his identity nor masculinity is in any way threatened, and in fact, he is passionate about her profession, success, and talent. He’s damn proud of her.

I get that this isn’t everyone’s idea of normal – but it will be, and soon.

We women are out in full swing and that wage gap is closing. I’m not saying that all women will out-earn their male counterparts – nor should we, just for having the second X chromosome. But I am saying that men won’t have to be the default provider anymore.

And I’m willing to bet that’ll alleviate some of the pressure men feel.

We don’t need the man to financially support us. Relationships now are about more than a transfer of property ownership and a cushy shared nest egg. Trust that if you find someone who likes you, maybe in this day and age it can be about more than just free dinners and a safety net.

So let’s do away with the awkwardness and drama. For us ladies, no more expecting men to foot the bill. No more MRS degrees. But also no more shying away from being successful.

For the fellas, embrace your successful lady! Don’t embarrass your friends if they’re splitting the bill, don’t second-guess your personal value because you don’t make 6 figures, and try not to belittle our jobs by insinuating that women can only be successful if they look a certain way.

Let’s all take a page out of my mom’s book and own our success, and let’s also take a page out of my dad’s book and truly support our partner’s success. It’s time to grow up and treat each other as equals, historical and cultural norms be damned.

My favorite free financial tool I use is M1 Finance. I've previously written about M1's free trades, automatic rebalancing, and easy-to-use interface, but it really does make investing accessible and easy. If you're not already investing in some way, or if you're looking for a tool that makes it easy to manage, I recommend trying it out.

You can also sign up to have my most recent articles sent straight to your email inbox for free!

10 thoughts on “Kill the Traditional Breadwinner

  1. While my wife chose, her choice, to stay home and raise kids and manage our lives and I did the 9 to 5 there was no doubt in mine, hers or any of our friends’ minds who the strong fearless one was, and it wasn’t me. I was great at making money but not at much else and she was great at running a family and turning kids into great adults. It was traditional in a lot of ways and it has worked for 39 years but that was just us, no doubt it could work just as well for others if the roles were reversed. Great post!

    • Thank you! I’m all for people making their own decisions and couples doing whatever works for them. I just hate the idea that, in this day and age, so many people are restricted by their gender. Whether you’re a woman whose professional value is overlooked or a man who feels pressure to be the provider, it’s a problem on both sides.

      Also, congratulations on 39 years. Very impressive!

  2. Traditionally men have been willing to marry ‘down’ in financial and societal aspects eg. a rich man would marry a poor woman. But now the paradigm has been swapped and women are leading I guess a lot of men are waiting to see if women in general provide the same courtesy. This will be one of the historical and social norms to shake off. I personally don’t know of any man that say’s “I can’t wait to go to work for 50 hours (minimum) this week” – I am starting to thank Feminism for liberating men like this. I would much rather spend time at home with the kids and take control back of the home and get the wife to work if she wants to be the one to take that path. Traditionally men have looked forward to retiring and spending time at home…not working. Thank you feminism.

    • I totally agree. Equal partnerships can only help. We can build our lives to what we want, not what is associated with our chromosomes.

      Honestly, feminism has such a bad rep because people don’t understand that it’s about equality. The unnecessary gender norms we have hurt men just as they hurt women.

  3. Uggggggh, yep. I’m an engineer, and I make more than double what my boyfriend makes. (On an hourly basis. I make 4x as much since he only works half time while he’s in school.) He’s totally cool with me treating him, but his family definitely teases him about it. It’s weird; my family’s religious and his isn’t, but they are way more uptight about gender roles. Whatever. I’m super stubborn and get a kick out of proving people wrong, so it doesn’t really wear on me.

    • Yas, queen. Keep doing what you’re doing, and don’t feel bad about being the higher earner. Partnerships are for partners, and if you two are happy with your system, why mess with it? His family will catch up someday.

  4. Have to love millennial dating right? As a single guy it’s tough as I’m all about splitting the check on the first date, though many times I feel like I’m expected to pick it up (not that I have a problem with that). Whether that’s just from the societal “standard” that’s been set from so many years ago, or from the individual women I meet with, I’m not sure.

    To get around this I try to have fun with it and say something like I’ll grab this one, and maybe you take the next one (thus saying I’m interested in another date, and it’s essentially like we split both), but seeing as I’m still single it clearly hasn’t worked out for me yet 😂

    Best of luck out there 😄

Leave a Reply